Before anyone gets the wrong impression, let me just say that I sincerely like social media. It’s where I keep up with an ever-growing list of interests, from politics and green energy to marketing and sci-fi and beyond. I blog a lot myself, and run a few wikis and social discussions about writing, movies, and sucky consumer products. I tweet a few times a day. I’m on Facebook and LinkedIn.
I give presentations on “Marketing 2.0″ and how the world of marketing is changing toward more conversations. I’ve recently penned a series of articles for IBM DeveloperWorks that explore different aspects of Twitter (like how ot build a Twitter-like tool for a PHP application, how to integrate with the Twitter API, and more).
Furthermore, I’m old enough to have used CompuServe, Prodigy, and Usenet. I’m old school, yeah, but I’ve always known that the Internet was about connecting people together, not just computers.
So, I get it, okay?
However, it’s time to talk turkey about social media and its effects on marketers. Marketers are more accustomed to a “fire and forget” type of framework in their daily work. You spend six weeks or six months putting together a brochure, birthing a white paper, or launching a microsite, and then you want to go out and have a martini afterward. Check! Next!
What this classic framework lacks is meaningful conversation and interaction. If someone loves your white paper, you hardly ever find out about it. You’ve already moved on. Guess what? That’s not going to fly if you launch a blog. If you’re good at what you do, and if you do it right, you’re going to end up with people leaving comments, blogging about you, whatever. See you want this, because the number one benefit you get from this is insight.
Marketers are going to need people to help respond to these inbound requests as part of the insight gathering. It’s not just polite, it’s critical.
Even more so, they’ll need people to figure out what they should be talking about, what others are already saying, and all that. If it sounds like you’re on 24/7, well, you kind of are. And because current social media channels are spread to hell and gone (monitoring Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, your own blog, your competitors’ blogs, and various “fan” social networks will make you pine for the days of public pay phones and no email) it means that you will need people who are adept at multitasking, a kind of social media ADHD. What we need are much easier ways to manage all of this.
Here’s something else that we’re all pretty much facing now. Take a look at your Twitter Follower list, your LinkedIn network, your FaceBook friends. Give me $10 for every person on there you don’t know or can’t remember. Or can’t stand to be around. No bet? Then join the Oversubscribed Club. I have a feeling that all kinds of people and brands are going to find a way to rethink the “We Must Expand Our Reach” model, make this thing more about intimate conversations, or at least, migrate to technologies that allow us to be more targeted in our conversations.
Some of this will be solved by our current economic reality. It seems that 99% of social media companies had a very simple business model: get lots of people to show up, then we’ll figure out something. Sounds familiar, right? Web 2.0 suffered from the same general malaise as Web 1.0 there at the end of the go-go 90s.
We’re already starting to hear the heart break as services shut down. Again, nothing new there, but this time around it has a different tone to it. It feels a lot more personal now. Maybe with Web 3.0 we’ll figure out the business model first, then roll stuff out to make people happy. Don’t count on it, though.
Of course, trimming the fat can cause heartburn. For a decade now, it’s been about page views, clicks, and referrer sources. Now its about followers, number of comments, votes up and down. Going out and actually cutting followers and such is tantamount to suicide. Many C-suite executives at B2B companies are still in “wait and see” mode when it comes to the old metrics (I mean, so what if we have all this traffic, can Marketing save its own neck by showing bottom-line value?), much less the new stuff. They see lots of press coverage on the subject (Will it Blend? Obama Girl! Yada, yada, yada), but they’re watching marketers try to integrate Twitter and Facebook and blogging with trade booths, white papers, and display ads.
And don’t kid yourself for one second that having a bunch of followers is as good as say, a fully optimized landing page that sells $10,000 worth of software product every day. Or 1000 channel partners that sell half-a-million in product and training every year. Or a monthly webinar series that leads to a million dollars worth of engagements each quarter. When social media can show us it can do that, well then, there’ll be some very excited C-suite executives out there.
Of course, what will most likely happen is the reverse. Every company will sooner or later have that awful moment tailor-made for social media rescue. It’s the same as with other communications channel. No one ever thinks of the PR person until the CEO is caught laundering money for the Triads or something.
Personal brands are on the rise, too, and they’re starting to compete with corporate brands. What if your employee who handles social media for you from 9 to 5 also has 5,000 followers on Twitter and a bangin’ blog (or network of blogs)? What happens when that employee can’t handle the restrictions of your top-down corporate culture, or the product roadmap takes a left turn down a hard road, yeah, that left turn down that road, the one he keeps warning you not to go down? What if you come in to work one day to find that something this guy has said on Twitter has been retweeted and blogged 700 times and made it to the top of Digg and Mixx and Reddit?
Which brand wins in that case? I’m willing to bet the guy gets Dooced, and you’re now back to trying to find good people who can engage in conversations, instead of just picking up a megaphone and shouting at everyone.
At the end of the day, social media tools are extremely effective when it comes to interacting with a particular niche, and I’m pretty optimistic about its role in the future of marketing. However, before we get to that happy land, we’re going to see quite a few detours, bumps, and breakdowns during 2009.